At least seven Bonfim families told their leases will not be renewed
The 15 houses on Rua das Eirinhas, home to 45 people, went to a Póvoa de Varzim builder in a swap for a €230,000 studio flat in Boavista.

At least seven of the 15 families on Rua das Eirinhas, in Bonfim, have letters dated 12 November telling them their leases will not be renewed. The letters come from José Salgado & Mário Moreira, a construction and property company from Póvoa de Varzim that now owns the houses, and most give April 2027 as the date to leave. The houses stand between the Igreja do Bonfim and Avenida de Fernão de Magalhães, near the centre of Porto, and 45 people live in them, most of them elderly.
For most of the households, the letters mean finding another place to live. Amélia Soares has been in her house for 74 years. She says most of the residents are in their 70s and that their pensions would not cover a rent of €800. José Fernandes Martins, the lawyer advising the families, says the leases are old, and that if building work goes ahead the tenants over 65 must be rehoused in Bonfim or a neighbouring parish.
The houses belonged to the Diocese do Porto, the Catholic Church's administrative body for the Porto area. They had been left to the Seminário de Vilar, the diocese's seminary, in a will dated 5 June 1963. The deed that moved them on is dated 10 January 2025. The 15 houses went into the swap at a declared total of €230,000, about €15,000 each, the same value the company put on the studio flat it is to build in Boavista.
The deal was a permuta, a swap of property rather than a sale. Because it was not a sale, the tenants could not use their right of first refusal, the direito de preferência, the right a sitting tenant has to be offered the property before it goes to anyone else. Some of the families have sought legal advice to fight the eviction, and the residents argue the swap was a simulated transaction designed to get round that right.
Emílio Borges, a resident, values the whole set at €200,000, against €370,000 for an identical house in the same area. Rui Moreira, then mayor of Porto, said in April 2025 that the aim had clearly been to stop the residents exercising their right of first refusal, and the city council its own in Miragaia. He said the city would have paid much more than €15,000 for each house.
The council had said in February 2025 that it could not exercise its own right of first refusal over the Eirinhas, because the area had no urban rehabilitation operation, the city designation that gives it that power. In April 2025 councillors discussed a recommendation that the city express its indignation at the disposals. No licensing application for the area had been filed as of April 2025.
The Diocese do Porto says it does not know the situation and refers questions to the current owner. In 2025 the diocese said the swaps were not made with the intention of raising capital, that the property is not for sale, and that it was meant to promote more housing in the city and the upkeep of the housing already there. It said certified valuers had priced the buildings taking their current occupation into account, and that the point was to gather church property scattered around the city in one place. Mário Moreira, a partner in the company, told Correio da Manhã in 2025 that "the residents have no right because these are swaps". The diocese has also swapped three buildings in Miragaia and one in Boavista, all let at old rents.
Parliament is still to vote, in the coming days, on proposals in the 2027 budget that would limit landlords' refusals to renew leases. Proposals to stop evictions were among those already voted down.
The daily digest
Porto’s news in one email
Everything worth knowing from Porto and Portugal, in English, six mornings a week.
Get the daily digest →Opens downriverporto.substack.com. Unsubscribe any time.